What brokers should look for when choosing a CHOICE Arrangement (ICHRA) partner

By Elizabeth Walker on Nov 18, 2026, 2:30:22 PM

What Brokers Should Look for When Choosing a CHOICE Arrangement (ICHRA) Partner

Choosing the right CHOICE Arrangement administrator is more than finding a vendor that offers a robust, software-only platform. Broker consultants need a full-service partner that can support clients throughout the benefits life cycle, from plan design and employee onboarding to compliance management and ongoing administration. The right partner should also strengthen the broker-client relationship, not try to replace the broker’s role.

However, evaluating these capabilities can be challenging, especially if you’re new to the CHOICE Arrangement, formerly called the individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement (ICHRA), and don’t know which questions to ask to choose a partner that can support your and your clients’ needs.

What to know:

  • Look for a full-service CHOICE Arrangement administrator with the technology, carrier relationships, and years of expertise to support employers and employees year-round.
  • Consider more than the employee shopping experience. Look at other necessary features, such as enrollment processing, premium payments, compliance, and ongoing administration.
  • Choose a partner that supports your client relationships and offers dedicated broker support.

What brokers should look for when choosing a CHOICE Arrangement partner

Not all CHOICE Arrangement vendors are the same. To find the right partner for your clients, you must look beyond the platform itself and consider everything that goes into launching and maintaining an effective employer-sponsored health benefit.

"As a brokerage evaluating CHOICE Administration partners, it's vital to analyze each administrator's unseen processes and capabilities just as much as those that are front and center,” said TJ Witham, VP of Broker Sales at Remodel Health. “It's relatively easy to evaluate each CHOICE Administrator's employee plan shopping application, but it's much harder to know what backend process, system, and support-related questions to ask."

"As a brokerage evaluating CHOICE Administration partners, it's vital to analyze each administrator's unseen processes and capabilities just as much as those that are front and center. It's relatively easy to evaluate each CHOICE Administrator's employee plan shopping application, but it's much harder to know what backend process, system, and support-related questions to ask."
TJ Witham Staff

TJ Witham

VP of Broker Sales, Remodel Health

The following nine criteria and questions can help you assess potential CHOICE Arrangement partners.

1. A partner that understands the broker consultant relationship

Your CHOICE Arrangement administrator should value your insight and expertise, not ignore it. As a benefits consultant, you’ve spent significant time building trust with your clients, and they likely see you as a trusted source of information. Choosing an administrative partner shouldn't put those relationships at risk.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • Will I remain the primary benefits advisor and point of contact for my client?
  • How does the vendor communicate with brokers throughout the implementation and renewal processes?
  • How does the CHOICE Arrangement administrator handle broker compensation and carrier relationships?
  • Does the administrator provide resources and education to help me grow my CHOICE Arrangement business?

Remodel Health views broker consultants as essential to delivering successful CHOICE Arrangements to employers of all sizes. Our team works alongside brokers to help them evaluate benefit strategies, design contributions, implement plans, and support their clients and their employees throughout the year.

Brokers also receive ongoing assistance, educational resources, and access to experienced benefits professionals while maintaining their client relationships. Through Remodel Health's proprietary online ICHRA Academy, brokers can learn more about the ICHRA so they can better serve their clients. We also offer a comprehensive broker quoting platform with customizable dashboards, making it easier to build proposals and manage client opportunities.

Learn more about how Remodel Health values the broker relationship

2. Dedicated implementation support and a simple onboarding process

An effective CHOICE Arrangement launch requires more than an employee shopping platform. Employers need help defining their health benefits strategy, designing their plan, and preparing for employee enrollment. A good administrator should have an implementation process that comes with clearly defined responsibilities, timelines, and employee communications.

Without a structured plan, important details can fall through the cracks, creating unnecessary work for broker consultants and HR teams.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • Is there a dedicated implementation team?
  • Who helps my client establish employee classes and contribution amounts?
  • How does the administrator collect necessary employee demographics and other pertinent information?
  • What legal documents and notices are required before launch?
  • How are brokers and employers kept informed about implementation progress?

Remodel Health provides a structured implementation process. Our dedicated Launch Coordinators and Account Executives work side by side with broker consultants and employers to gather employee census information, review existing benefit plans, evaluate contribution strategies, and prepare the CHOICE Arrangement for launch. We also help employers customize contributions by employee classes, prepare legal plan documents, and send out required employee notices.

3. Strong carrier relationships and enrollment support

Individual health plan shopping is just the first step when onboarding employees to their new CHOICE Arrangement. Enrolling in individual coverage requires coordination between the employee, the administrator, and the health insurance carrier. If applications aren't correctly processed or enrollment information isn't communicated accurately, employees may experience coverage delays or gaps.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • How many individual market carriers does the administrator work with?
  • Can employees access plans across different states and insurance markets?
  • Who processes and monitors insurance company enrollments?
  • How are application errors, enrollment delays, and coverage discrepancies resolved?
  • What happens when a carrier needs more information regarding the employee’s application?

Remodel Health has spent more than a decade developing carrier relationships in the individual health insurance market nationwide. Our team helps employees understand their coverage options, supports enrollment processing, and works with carriers to address application and coverage issues. Our off-exchange carrier relationships also help expand the range of CHOICE Arrangement-specific plan options available to employees.

4. A reliable premium payment system with built-in safeguards

Premium payments are one of the most important parts of managing a successful CHOICE Arrangement. Even after employees enroll in health plans, payment problems can put their coverage at risk. A great administrator should have a reliable process for collecting employer contributions and paying insurance carriers. Broker consultants must understand how the system works to avoid missed or incorrect payments that can frustrate their clients.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • How are individual health insurance premiums paid?
  • Does the administrator automate premium payments?
  • How does the vendor verify that payments are accurate and received on time?
  • What safeguards are in place to prevent missed payments or funding issues?
  • Who monitors payment exceptions and resolves carrier billing discrepancies?

Remodel Health simplifies premium payments through its secure funding system and AutoPay technology. Employers deposit their monthly contributions into FDIC-insured bank accounts, and funds are distributed to virtual accounts for each employee plan. AutoPay processes individual coverage premium payments with more than 99% accuracy. Our team keeps an eye on payment activity and resolves any issues that come up.

Additionally, overdraft protection helps reduce the chance that a funding issue disrupts premium payments.

5. Licensed Benefits Advisors and employee support

Employees who are familiar with traditional group health plans may have little to no experience shopping for individual coverage. Self-service tools can make enrolling in an individual plan easier, but some employees will likely need extra help. Broker consultants should review whether the CHOICE Arrangement vendor they’re considering offers knowledgeable, licensed professionals who can help employees make informed coverage decisions.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • Are licensed benefits advisors available to help employees compare health insurance plans?
  • Can employees receive one-on-one enrollment guidance from the vendor?
  • Are support options available to employees?
  • How does the administrator educate employees who are unfamiliar with individual coverage?
  • Is there dedicated support for employees approaching Medicare eligibility?

Remodel Health combines easy-to-use technology with expert guidance from licensed Benefits Advisors who are available via chat, email, and phone. Employees with more complicated coverage situations can get support understanding their plan options, comparing individual health policies, and completing enrollment. Our team also provides year-round member support, including in-house assistance for employees navigating Medicare.

6. Comprehensive compliance and reporting support

Like traditional group health plans, CHOICE Arrangements have federal compliance requirements that employers must meet throughout the plan year. Broker consultants should understand exactly which compliance responsibilities their client must meet and ask the administrator what obligations it handles and what the employer or brokerage must tackle.

A vendor that only provides software may leave complex administrative work with the employer, which can result in penalties if they make a mistake.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • Does the administrator prepare required plan documents and employee notices?
  • How does it verify employee eligibility and substantiate individual health coverage?
  • Does the vendor help applicable large employers (ALEs) satisfy the ACA’s employer mandate?
  • Does it help with required tax filing, such as Forms 1094 and 1095, Form 720, and PCORI fees?
  • Who monitors regulatory changes and communicates updates to brokers and employers?

Remodel Health provides comprehensive compliance support throughout the entire plan year. Our team helps prepare required plan documents, including summary plan descriptions (SPDs), the summary of benefits and coverage (SBC), and employee notices. We also help determine affordable contribution amounts for ALEs and provide guidance with tax filing, including Forms 1094 and 1095 and other required IRS forms.

Our Compliance Bundle is also available and includes ACA 1095 reporting and filing services, plus full COBRA administration.

We keep you updated on any regulatory or compliance changes that may affect your benefit throughout the year so you avoid any costly fines.

7. Payroll and HRIS integrations that reduce administrative work

Even if a CHOICE Arrangement is new to your clients, it shouldn’t interfere with the administrative processes they already use. Without reliable tools and connections, HR teams may have to take on more manual tasks, such as updating employee records, reconciling information, and communicating changes across multiple systems. This would increase your client’s administrative workload and the likelihood of errors.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • Does the benefit administrator platform integrate with the client’s existing systems?
  • Are employee hires, terminations, and eligibility changes synced automatically?
  • How often does information update?
  • How are integration errors identified and resolved?
  • Can the administrator support employers with multiple locations or complex workforces?

Remodel Health with ClearChoice™ connects directly with several payroll and HRIS providers — including ADP Workforce Now, Paylocity, UKG Pro, Workday, and Dayforce — with more connections available through Finch if you need more options to support your workforce.

Our team monitors the connection to identify and resolve problems before the integration goes live. Then, the integrations automatically synchronize employee information, eligibility, and payroll data, even if your client’s workforce information changes. This way, everything moves seamlessly between our platform and the employer's existing systems.

Learn how our HRIS and payroll integrations can reduce manual work for your clients

8. The ability to scale as the client’s company grows

Different-sized companies have different needs. A smaller company with 30 employees may need an easy-to-use, affordable solution, while a larger employer with several hundred workers may require a customizable plan design with greater support.

Broker consultants should choose an administrator with the experience and infrastructure to support their current clients and accommodate more complex needs as their client’s organization grows.

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • Does the administrator have experience with employers of different sizes?
  • Can it support multistate workforces and multiple employee classes?
  • Does its technology accommodate complex contribution strategies?
  • Can its service model support both smaller and larger employers?
  • Does it have the staffing and infrastructure to maintain service quality as it grows?

Remodel Health supports employers across the U.S., with administration capabilities designed for both smaller businesses and large, complex organizations. Our Remodel Health with ClearChoice product provides full-service CHOICE Arrangement administration for larger employers with more complex needs. Our PeopleKeep product offers a streamlined, software-based solution for small businesses — even if they’re a multi-state company with remote workers. This gives brokers different service models to choose from that can meet every organization’s needs as they grow.

9. A proven track record with verifiable results

Even if a vendor seems like the right choice, broker consultants should also look for evidence that the administrator can deliver. In the health benefits industry, experience matters, and ensuring your client’s CHOICE Arrangement is successful requires a partner that understands the ins and outs of the benefit and has the knowledge and experience to back it up.

"Carrier enrollment processing, premium payment accuracy, and compliance support services are critical pieces of information to ask when looking for a CHOICE Arrangement partner,” said Witham. “This can be even tougher for brokers who are new to CHOICE Arrangements and haven't experienced the pain when the basics needed to run the benefit successfully aren’t done well."

"Carrier enrollment processing, premium payment accuracy, and compliance support services are critical pieces of information to ask when looking for a CHOICE Arrangement partner. This can be even tougher for brokers who are new to CHOICE Arrangements and haven't experienced the pain when the basics needed to run the benefit successfully aren’t done well."
TJ Witham Staff

TJ Witham

VP of Broker Sales, Remodel Health

Questions to ask a potential partner:

  • How long has the administrator been supporting CHOICE Arrangements?
  • How many employers and employees does it currently serve?
  • Can it provide customer case studies?
  • What is its client retention rate?
  • Does it have dedicated teams for implementation, account management, financial operations, and employee support?

Remodel Health was founded in 2015 and has spent more than a decade deepening its expertise with CHOICE Arrangements and the individual market. With the acquisition of PeopleKeep in 2024, it has a legacy in the HRA and individualized benefits space going back to 2006. Today, we serve more than 6,000 companies across all 50 states and D.C., with a growing team of 240+ employees providing dedicated implementation, enrollment, compliance, and payment support.

Our experience serving employers of all industries and sizes, along with a 95% customer retention rate, gives brokers peace of mind, knowing their clients are supported every step of the way.

Read our customer success stories to see how we’ve helped companies just like yours

Conclusion

Choosing a CHOICE Arrangement administrator is one of the most important decisions a broker consultant can make when recommending the benefit to clients. The right partner should offer more than just the basics. It should offer an innovative platform, carrier relationships, compliance expertise, and a dedicated support team to make the benefit work long-term.

At Remodel Health, we combine full-service administration, purpose-built technology, and personalized support to help broker consultants deliver flexible CHOICE Arrangements (formerly known as ICHRA). We work alongside brokers to simplify the administrative process, protect their client relationships, and provide employers and employees with a better benefits experience.

Partner with Remodel Health to learn how we can help you grow your book of business

Frequently asked questions

What does a CHOICE Arrangement administrator do?

A CHOICE Arrangement administrator helps employers design, implement, and manage their health benefits through the plan year and renewal. Services may include benefits design, such as choosing contribution amounts, determining eligibility using employee classes, and drafting legal plan documents. Employee education, benefit enrollment, premium payments, and ongoing customer support are also important services to look for when considering vendors. 

What should brokers look for in a CHOICE Arrangement administrator?

Broker consultants should review an administrator's benefit features, carrier relationships, enrollment process, compliance services, and HRIS and payroll integration capabilities. They should also investigate how the CHOICE Arrangement administrator handles broker-client relationships. 

How do CHOICE Arrangement administrators support brokers?

A full-service CHOICE Arrangement administrator offers brokers implementation assistance, quoting tools, client management resources, benefit utilization reports, and year-round account management. The right partner works alongside broker consultants rather than replacing them as the client's main health benefits advisor. 

Who helps employees enroll in a CHOICE Arrangement?

Depending on the administrator, employees may receive self-service enrollment tools, educational resources, or one-on-one assistance from licensed benefits advisors.  

How are individual health insurance premiums paid through a CHOICE Arrangement?

Premium payment processes vary by administrator. Some require employees to pay premiums themselves and receive reimbursements, while others, like Remodel Health, offer automated premium payments. Brokers should ask how the vendor’s payment process works, including whether they monitor and protect against missed payments or coverage disruptions. 

What compliance support should a CHOICE Arrangement administrator provide?

A good CHOICE Arrangement administrator should help employers draft and manage plan documents and employee notices and verify individual coverage. Applicable large employers (ALEs) should also receive assistance calculating affordability to comply with the employer mandate and satisfy ACA reporting requirements. Broker consultants should clarify which tasks the administrator handles and which are the employer’s responsibilities.